Essay Writing – Newness Not Taught in Textbooks Or By Teachers

Let me let you know, up entrance, crucial factor in writing:

………………………………………………………..What’s new to the reader.

“Massive deal!” it’s possible you’ll say. “My English trainer tells me that sort of stuff on a regular basis! She’s continuously saying, ‘Inform me one thing NEW and INTERESTING! Present me that you simply’re considering for your self!’

“Oh, yeah—–she additionally says, ‘And keep in mind Thoreau and Walden Pond! Simplify! However for pity’s sake, above all, make sure you say one thing NEW!‘”

Oh—–so “What’s new to the reader” would not sound particularly new to you, is that it?

All righty, then—–Let me ask you simply six inquiries to make clear why what your trainer stated about writing one thing new has at all times annoyed you (proper?) and to exhibit why that recommendation (from the most effective textbooks on the market) by no means actually helped you:


  • Does she present you a course of for getting “what’s new?”
  • Does she outline newness when it comes to what’s previous?
  • Does she train the 5 main sorts of OLD that NEW cannot exist with out?
  • Does she let you know the 5 main totally different sorts of NEW?
  • Does she present you the way all the things in writing relates on to What’s new to the reader?
  • Does she level out how and the place What’s new to the reader is used on a regular basis by writers of revealed essays, quick tales, and novels?


See what I imply? However let’s not blame the teacher—–that’s the best way she was educated.

Academics aren’t the one ones who’re imprecise about newness in writing. A number of supposed writing students have informed me that newness in writing is taught in lots of fashionable composition textbooks. Humorous factor, though—–these supposedly educated students all suggest books and guarantee me that the precept of newness is already taught in these books, however once I dutifully learn the books they suggest, I am unable to discover what they are saying must be there.

As an illustration, a kind of beneficial books that did not ship on instructing newness is They Say, I Say (2006) by Gerald Graff and Cathy Birkenstein. These authors really deny that they supply something however types or templates, leaving content material and newness as much as the author to generate. Here is what they are saying on web page 11 of their e book:


Moreover, these templates don’t dictate the content material of what you say, which may be as authentic as you may make it, however solely counsel a manner of formatting how you say it.


As you’ll be able to clearly see from this quote, the authors straightforwardly admit that the templates they train are just for “counsel[ing] a manner of formatting” (kind) and don’t have anything to do with producing content material and newness.

The strangest referral I’ve had from a writing scholar was to the whole work of Professor John Swales, a famous linguist who has labored primarily with style evaluation in utilized linguistics. After I made some unsuccessful analysis makes an attempt to discover a means of newness taught in his works, I discovered his handle and emailed Professor Swales straight.

Professor Swales graciously replied that my informant was “misinformed,” though he admitted that the informant could be referring to his research on introductions,


and the way they attempt to set up a spot in earlier data with a view to pave the best way for saying that the upcoming contribution presents one thing new.


Professor Swales referred me particularly to his e book, Style Evaluation (1990), Chapter 7, Analysis articles in English, Introductions, pages 137-166. In Chapter 7, he does certainly spend about thirty pages to refer to newness, however solely in phrases regarding creating contexts to introduce vital, related newness. There you’ve it—–“set up a spot” to “pave the best way for saying that the upcoming contribution presents one thing new,” similar to They Say, I Say—–form, not producing newness of content material.

One other e book I have been referred to incessantly is The Allyn & Bacon Information to Writing. That could be a superb e book, and it does refer to newness. However, additionally like so many different Write my argumentative essay textbooks, it nonetheless doesn’t present a course of for producing newness, nor does it acknowledge the basic centrality of newness to each thesis and to all of the assist for it in each essay. In brief, newness will get much less consideration than matter sentences or paragraph growth.

You see, it would not matter how rhetorically right an essay is, and even whether or not it’s impeccably organized and grammatically perfect—if the thesis and the assist for it should not new to the reader, then that essay is a failure.

Academics of writing ought to focus college students on the only most necessary precept in writing essays and all the things else—–

………………………………………………………..What’s new to the reader.

This text was written by Invoice Drew, a writing professional who makes a speciality of instructing writing of many sorts and ranges, in each principle and follow, particularly essay writing, essay matters [], essay examples [], thesis writing, matter sentences, and analysis writing — with insightful emphasis in instructing writing about literature, in addition to writing promoting and different enterprise writing.

He’s the writer of The Secret DNA of Writing Essays-And Every little thing Else, in addition to The Secret DNA of Analyzing Brief Tales. The 2 e-books plus software program for the primary e-book can be found at his web site, at, and at Drew is presently writing a 3rd e book, The Secret DNA of Subject Sentences That Entice Readers, which can be revealed on his web site and Amazon by September 14, 2010.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *